Complete dog food or a topper? Check the intended use first

Start with the product, not the photograph

FEDIAF distinguishes complete foods, intended to supply the required nutrients when used as directed, from complementary foods that are only part of a diet. US labels use nutritional adequacy statements discussed in AAFCO's consumer guidance; some products are intended for intermittent or supplemental feeding. Neither an attractive picture nor the word fresh settles that question. Read the wording on the specific recipe and pack size.

Record the country version

Create a line in your notes for country of sale, recipe, pack size and intended life stage. A brand's US page is not evidence for its Canadian product, and an Australian listing should not be replaced with a screenshot from a UK retailer. For Canada or Australia, ask the local supplier to explain the statement on the pack you will receive. This worksheet does not assume identical labelling rules across the four markets.

Build a two-column shopping list

Our suggested worksheet separates the food being considered as the main diet from optional extras. Place toppers, treats and similar additions in the second column until their role is clear. Combining several supplementary products does not establish that the result is nutritionally complete. If you want to change a substantial part of the diet, discuss the plan with your veterinarian rather than inventing a ratio from package pictures.

Ask one precise question

Try this message: 'For this recipe and pack sold in my country, is it intended as a complete main food or as an addition? Which life stage is it intended for, and where can I read the feeding instructions?' Include the product link. A reply about a different recipe does not answer the question. Keep the response with your order confirmation so that another person in the household can find it.

Leave missing information visible

Write 'not provided' instead of guessing. This is particularly useful when a retailer shows only the front of the pack. Request a readable photograph before ordering a large quantity. You do not need to award a brand a public score to decide that you need more information. A short list of unresolved questions is often more useful than a complicated comparison spreadsheet.

Check the first delivery

Match the delivered recipe and local label with your notes. A replacement product or changed formula deserves another check. Save a photograph of the relevant statements before storing the food. For repeat deliveries, add this to your unpacking routine. It is a product identity check, not proof of suitability for an individual dog with a medical condition.

Frequently asked questions

Keep exploring